2019 

First Round

Misericordia 12, Endicott 10 
Box Score | Recap 

2018

First Round

No. 16 William Smith 18, Endicott 8 
Box Score | Recap

2017

First Round

Farmingdale St. 16, Endicott 14
Box Score | Recap 

2014

Second Round

Middlebury 19, Endicott 7
Box Score | Recap 

2013

First Round

Endicott 4, Springfield 3
Box Score | Recap 

Second Round

Middlebury 13, Endicott 4
Box Score | Recap 

2012

First Round

Colby 21, Endicott 5
Box Score | Recap 

2011

First Round

Tufts 17, Endicott 6
Box Score | Recap 

2010

First Round

Claremont Mudd Scripps 21, Endicott 18
Box Score | Recap 

2009

First Round

Williams 19, Endicott 9
Box Score | Recap 

2008

First Round

Amherst 16, Endicott 7
Box Score | Recap 

2007

First Round

Trinity (Conn.) 19, Endicott 3
Box Score | Recap 

2006

First Round

Colorado Col. 13, Endicott 12
Box Score | Recap