Karen Baumann was a versatile three sport athlete in soccer, basketball and softball. The NJCAA named her an Academic All-American in soccer and softball with a 3.77 GPA in business. Baumann was the 1991 Regional Scholar Athlete of the Year and a member of the Endicott Varsity Club for academic excellence. She was a 1991 NJCAA All-New England and All-CSAC selection at shortstop with career batting average of .333.