| Season | Sport | Captains |
|---|---|---|
| 2017 | Women's Volleyball | Cydney Pierce, Lauren Sheehan, Mareena Clotfelter |
| 2016 | Women's Volleyball | Jayla Brennen, Tori McIntyre, Erika Trudon |
| 2015 | Women's Volleyball | Alleigh VandeMerkt, Lexi Watts, Erika Trudon |
| 2014 | Women's Volleyball | Jessica Petrucci, Alleigh VandeMerkt |
| 2013 | Women's Volleyball | Callie Dolan |
| 2012 | Women's Volleyball | Gillian Kucharski, Ashley Norley, Falyn Torelli |
| 2011 | Women's Volleyball | Sarah Allshouse, Elyse Barbour |
| 2010 | Women's Volleyball | Amy Grigg, Ally Murphy, Brittany Phillips |
| 2009 | Women's Volleyball | Stephanie Wiese, Ally Murphy |
| 2008 | Women's Volleyball | Beth Dow, Hayley Janelle |
| 2007 | Women's Volleyball | Meghan Hall, Beth Dow |
| 2006 | Women's Volleyball | Sara Moore, Katelyn Smith, Meghan Hall |
| 2005 | Women's Volleyball | Patty Mikan, Sara Moore, Killeen Ross |
| 2004 | Women's Volleyball | Krystan Sylva, Kristen Altieri, Killeen Ross |
| 2003 | Women's Volleyball | Krystan Sylva, Kristen Altieri |
| 2002 | Women's Volleyball | Krystan Sylva, Kristen Altieri |
| 2001 | Women's Volleyball | Jill DiOrio, Megan Rossetti |
| 2000 | Women's Volleyball | Susie Castillo, Samantha Lampert, Jill DiOrio |
| 1999 | Women's Volleyball | |
| 1998 | Women's Volleyball | |
| 1997 | Women's Volleyball | |
| 1996 | Women's Volleyball | |
| 1995 | Women's Volleyball | |
| 1994 | Women's Volleyball | |
| 1993 | Women's Volleyball |