| Season | Sport | Captains |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Softball | No captains |
| 2023 | Softball | No captains |
| 2022 | Softball | No captains |
| 2021 | Softball | No captains |
| 2020 | Softball | No captains |
| 2019 | Softball | Olivia Odermatt, Gina DeMilt, Hayley Arduini |
| 2018 | Softball | Lindsee Allienello, Olivia Odermatt, Emily Sharpe |
| 2017 | Softball | Chrissy Gikas, Julia McNeill |
| 2016 | Softball | Courtney Blake, Jamie Corda, Sam DiBella, Emily Hoffman |
| 2015 | Softball | Jamie Corda, Meg Donegan, Jess Linden |
| 2014 | Softball | Jesse Bilafer, Alexandra Moise, Nell O'Connor |
| 2013 | Softball | Jesse Bilafer, Byrne Katz, Jocelyn Russo |
| 2012 | Softball | Nicole Devlin, Byrne Katz |
| 2011 | Softball | Hayley Hovhanessian, Jenna Bortolotti |
| 2010 | Softball | Sarah Spaziano, Jenna Lazar |
| 2009 | Softball | Meghan Sargent, Casey Shanley, Jackie Collier |
| 2008 | Softball | Paula McGinn, Rachel Pearson |
| 2007 | Softball | Paula McGinn, Robyn Savitske |
| 2006 | Softball | Megan Huckins, Robyn Savitske |
| 2005 | Softball | Elyse Colby, Megan Young |
| 2004 | Softball | Kacy Beloin, Laura Mangini, Adrienne Guzman |
| 2003 | Softball | Becky Bell, Adrienne Leone |
| 2002 | Softball | Lili Doherty, Sarah Manville |
| 2001 | Softball | Elyse Colby, Katie Doherty, Megan Young |
| 2000 | Softball | Lyndsey Smith, Melissa Curry, Megan Huckins |
| 1999 | Softball | Amelia Griffin, Lyndsey Smith, Heidi Stevens |
| 1998 | Softball | Lisa Ferony, Melissa Tarpy |
| 1997 | Softball | Lisa Ferony, Melissa Tarpy, Kim Peckham |
| 1996 | Softball | Patricia Matthews, Jessica Giamberadino |
| 1995 | Softball | Victoria Wiedeman, Tara Mansour |
| 1994 | Softball | No captains |