| Season | Sport | Captains |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Men's Lacrosse | Ethan Cupples, Matt Cawley |
| 2023 | Men's Lacrosse | Domenic Masucci, Domenic Valera |
| 2022 | Men's Lacrosse | Ryan Fincher, James Loughran, Kevin Morency |
| 2021 | Men's Lacrosse | Calvin Driscoll, James Loughran, Jack Sutherland |
| 2020 | Men's Lacrosse | Andrew Soucy |
| 2019 | Men's Lacrosse | Grant Garrity, Justin Horine, Hayden Souza |
| 2018 | Men's Lacrosse | Josh Heidrick, Cole McGarrigle, Hayden Souza |
| 2017 | Men's Lacrosse | Tommy Hughes, Shane Hughes, Will Jennings |
| 2016 | Men's Lacrosse | Cameron Bell, Will Farfalla, Mitch Tapley |
| 2015 | Men's Lacrosse | Harrison Cotter |
| 2014 | Men's Lacrosse | Peter Erickson |
| 2013 | Men's Lacrosse | Kyle Burke, Peter Erickson, Connor McCormack, Ryan Sutherland |
| 2012 | Men's Lacrosse | Michael Armstrong, Chris O'Brien, Greg Szkop |
| 2011 | Men's Lacrosse | Chris Cotter, Bob Crossett, Jack Curtis, Chris Gugino |
| 2010 | Men's Lacrosse | Eric Hagarty, Brad Lipkvich |
| 2009 | Men's Lacrosse | Nick Cosco, Eddie O'Reilly, Adrian Peacock |
| 2008 | Men's Lacrosse | Nick Cosco, Eddie O'Reilly, Jon Ortolani |
| 2007 | Men's Lacrosse | Patrick Gaffney, Josh Gilbert, Dan Ryan |
| 2006 | Men's Lacrosse | Jesse Blackwell, Ryan Fraine, Kevin Lally, Ryan Walsh |
| 2005 | Men's Lacrosse | Jesse Blackwell, Burt Fahy, Marc MacMillan, Josh Maciorowski |
| 2004 | Men's Lacrosse | Scott Bartusch, Corey Fox, Paul Lord |
| 2003 | Men's Lacrosse | Matt Bagshaw, Matt Baker |
| 2002 | Men's Lacrosse | Matt Bagshaw, Jeff Maciorowski, Joe Mullock |
| 2001 | Men's Lacrosse | Jeff Maciorowski, Joe Mullock, Rick Riccio |
| 2000 | Men's Lacrosse | Tim Dunton, Jim Parton, Rick Riccio |
| 1999 | Men's Lacrosse | Frank Guidice, Chris Maher, Tom Maher, John Rebholz |
| 1998 | Men's Lacrosse | Frank Guidice, Chris Maher |
| 1997 | Men's Lacrosse | Frank Guidice, Chris Maher |
| 1996 | Men's Lacrosse | No captains |