| Season | Sport | Captains |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Football | Shane Aylward, Brendan Gill, Hector Johnson, Matthew Licciardi, Clayton Marengi, Colin Meropoulos, Zachariah Twardosky |
| 2023 | Football | Shane Aylward, Anthony Caggianelli, Colin Campbell, Hector Johnson, Matthew Licciardi, Joseph Pagett, Kyle Secone |
| 2022 | Football | Michael Awiszus, Shane Aylward, Tyler Davis, Nicholas Gaiero, Joseph Pagett, Kyle Secone |
| 2021 | Football | Shane Aylward, Wyatt Brennan, John Kenney, Sam Opont, Tim Russell, Mehdi Squalli |
| 2020 | Football | Dylan Bonfilio, Kyle Brennan, Kevin O'Brien, Sam Opont, Riley Shanley, Mehdi Squalli |
| 2019 | Football | Isaiah Gibbs, Kha-lil Goodman, Joe Kalosky, Tom Lorusso, Grayson Maddux, Shane Toland |
| 2018 | Football | Christian Pizzotti, William Rivera, Connor Schinderman, Shane Toland |
| 2017 | Football | Christian Filonow, Shane Toland |
| 2016 | Football | Craig Anderson, Chris Lipscomb |
| 2015 | Football | Craig Anderson, Tyler Calitri, Joe Picard, Mike Romanelli, Spencer Walsh |
| 2014 | Football | Jake Cox, Mike Marini, Luke Somers |
| 2013 | Football | Marcell Cooper, Greg Dellorco, Jason Silva |
| 2012 | Football | Jared DiBiase, Craig Lussier, Oscar Moore, Ian Suter |
| 2011 | Football | Taylor Allen, Kevin Eagan, Sean Gaffney, Bill Hickey, Phil Konopka, Mike Lane |
| 2010 | Football | Kevin Eagan, Mike Dillon, Bill Hickey, Kyle Capsalis, Luke Croxton |
| 2009 | Football | Dave Coflesky, Tim Viall, Dan Leary, Mike Carlin |
| 2008 | Football | Rob Brandt, Mike Angoff, Dan Orlando, George Samaras |
| 2007 | Football | Pego Jean-Paul, Jared Giblin, Nick Bauer, Alex Smith, Jay Munroe |
| 2006 | Football | Pego Jean-Paul, Angelo Perrina, Tim Boyd, Joe Leaver, Jay Munroe |
| 2005 | Football | Jesse Blackwell, Rob Velasquez, Jay Munroe |
| 2004 | Football | Jesse Blackwell, Mike Ciesco, Eric Fournier, Jay Munroe |
| 2003 | Football | Jesse Blackwell, Rob Velasquez, Andrew West, Jay Munroe |